rummess/Depositphotos.com
A man who inherited securities and land from his aunt paid approximately €47,000 in inheritance tax because the assets were classified as private wealth. Had he inherited a qualifying business, as much as 85% or even 100% of its value could have escaped tax. The Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe is now considering whether that difference in treatment remains constitutionally defensible.
The sums involved can be substantial. According to Federal Finance Ministry documents seen by Handelsblatt, only 34 large transfers qualified for Germany’s needs-based business exemption last year, but the tax waived in those cases totalled €3.7bn. That contrast does not itself prove unconstitutional treatment: business relief is intended to protect companies and employment. It does, however, explain why the private heir’s €47,000 bill has brought the system back before Karlsruhe.
The case is particularly relevant to property owners because the boundary between private and business wealth does not necessarily follow the nature of the underlying asset. A rented building will generally receive no business relief, whether held privately or classified as an administrative asset within a company, whereas a sufficiently large and commercially organised housing portfolio may qualify.
Karlsruhe heard this constitutional complaint earlier this month, one day after considering a separate challenge brought by Bavaria over federal inheritance-tax rules. The two proceedings could produce different outcomes, but together they expose the central tension within the system: private property has risen sharply in value while personal allowances have remained unchanged since 2009, yet qualifying business assets can still pass between generations largely or entirely free of tax.
Judgments could arrive during the first quarter of 2027. In 2014, approximately five months passed between the hearing of the court’s previous inheritance-tax case and its ruling.
Two sides of the tax divide
For eligible business assets worth up to €26m, 85% can generally remain untaxed if the business continues for at least five years and satisfies payroll conditions. Complete exemption is possible under stricter requirements, including a seven-year holding period.
Larger transfers can qualify for a needs-based exemption, under which tax is waived to the extent that the heir cannot meet it from half of their available non-business assets. Between 2021 and 2025, €11.1bn of the €11.8bn initially assessed under this test was waived, according to the Finance Ministry documents reported by Handelsblatt.
The court accepted in 2014 that protecting businesses and employment could justify preferential treatment. It nevertheless found that the privileges then available went too far, particularly for very large companies, prompting the reform introduced in 2016. Karlsruhe must now decide whether that reform corrected the inequality or reconstructed it in another form.
For property investors, the classification rules are critical. Let property is normally treated as administrative assets, or Verwaltungsvermögen, and excluded from business relief. An exception applies to housing companies whose principal purpose is letting residential property and whose operation requires a commercial business organisation.
The tax authorities generally presume that this condition is satisfied by portfolios containing more than 300 apartments, although the courts have interpreted the exception more narrowly and portfolio size alone does not guarantee relief. Subject to the remaining conditions, a large housing operation can therefore receive treatment unavailable to a family holding a smaller number of let properties.
Similar real estate may consequently face very different inheritance-tax burdens according to how it is owned, operated and classified. The claimant’s challenge therefore reaches family offices, private landlords and family-owned housing companies as well as operating businesses.
Bavaria’s separate case approaches the inequality from the other direction. Spouses can currently inherit €500,000 tax-free and children €400,000, allowances that have remained unchanged since 2009. Bavaria told the court that general prices had since risen by approximately 33%, detached-house prices by 97% and building-land prices by 146%. An allowance that once protected an ordinary family property can now expose part of the same economic asset to tax, particularly in expensive cities.
Owner-occupied homes can remain exempt where spouses or children continue living in them for ten years, subject in the latter case to a 200 sqm limit. The relief is therefore valuable but narrower than the headline allowance debate sometimes suggests.
Bavaria wants the Länder to set their own allowances and rates, arguing that inheritance-tax revenue belongs to them and regional property values differ substantially. The proposal encountered considerable resistance during the hearing. No other Land supported it, while the federal government, North Rhine-Westphalia and legal experts warned of tax competition and complexity. The judges’ questions also suggested scepticism. Bavaria may have demonstrated that static allowances increasingly expose property wealth to taxation without persuading the court that 16 competing systems provide the answer.
What a ruling could set in motion
The property industry is already making its case. Philip Hetzer, managing partner of Dahler Invest, argues that even under the higher personal allowances proposed by the SPD, heirs to apartment buildings in major cities could face tax bills large enough to encourage sales. Ulrich Creydt of Ypsilon Steuerberatungsgesellschaft warns that housing companies might sell apartments to meet the tax, pushing rents higher.
That argument requires qualification. A sale transfers ownership; it does not remove a home from the rental market, and its effect upon rents depends upon the buyer and what happens next. The stronger concern is liquidity: an heir can receive a valuable but illiquid property portfolio without receiving the cash required to pay the tax.
The political consequences could exceed either claimant’s individual case. The SPD wants a €900,000 lifetime allowance for inheritances within families, a further €100,000 for transfers from others and a separate €5m business allowance. Larger business transfers would be taxed progressively, with payments spread over as long as 20 years where jobs are protected. Most existing exemptions would disappear. The CDU/CSU rejects higher taxation of business succession and has preferred to await Karlsruhe.
A finding of unconstitutionality would force the coalition partners to negotiate a reform without prescribing its final shape. In 2014, the court declared the rules incompatible with the Basic Law rather than immediately void, allowing them to remain in force while Parliament devised replacements.
No rule has yet changed. Succession planning nevertheless depends upon assumptions about valuation, allowances, ownership structures and the liquidity available to meet a future tax bill. Karlsruhe is now testing whether similar property wealth can continue to carry materially different burdens according to the legal category in which the next generation receives it.