zaurrahimov/Depositphotos.com
For years, the liquidity problems in Germany’s open-ended property funds were most visible among smaller and more specialised products. The wider sector had already suffered falling valuations and persistent withdrawals. In late October, however, the pressure reached the redemption process of one of its flagships.
DWS activated a partial redemption restriction in its €4.1bn grundbesitz europa fund on 27th October. Orders falling due that day were met in full, but those falling due from 28th October are initially being met at only 10% of the amount requested. The remaining 90% lapses. Anyone still wishing to redeem those units must submit another irrevocable request and, where applicable, wait a further twelve months.
The restriction can remain in place for up to a year, although DWS may alter the payout ratio or remove it earlier. It applies to previously submitted orders falling due during that period, including those from investors who began the redemption process twelve months ago.
“We are aware that the decision to activate the redemption restriction may cause personal hardship for investors,” said Christian Bäcker, managing director of DWS Grundbesitz. He argues that limiting payouts will give the fund time to sell properties in an orderly manner rather than under pressure.
As recently as September, DWS said it had no plans to suspend redemptions, while acknowledging that it was examining the liquidity-management instruments introduced this year. It has now opted for a gate rather than a full suspension. To an investor receiving one-tenth of the money requested, the distinction may feel rather technical.
Stefan Loipfinger of Investmentcheck, a longstanding critic of the funds, says a 90% shortfall comes close to a full redemption freeze. On 26th October, grundbesitz europa units traded on the exchange at €16.11, less than half the fund’s official redemption price.
The exchange market is thin, and its prices reflect illiquidity, transaction costs and uncertainty over when investors will recover their capital, as well as expectations about the underlying properties. The discount does not prove that the fund’s real estate is worth half its appraised value. It is nevertheless a severe verdict on what the funds’ redemption promise is currently worth.
The twelve-month queue reaches the gate
DWS’s decision capped a bleak fortnight for the sector. On 13th October, Catella terminated the management of Catella MAX, a Munich-focused fund, and began winding it up. On 20th October, Swiss Life suspended redemptions from its €762m European Real Estate Living and Working fund because it lacked sufficient liquidity both to repay investors and manage its 37 properties.
Swiss Life had sold six assets for approximately €220m since 2024 and returned around €300m to investors, but withdrawals continued. Its units were trading in late October at roughly €4.50 to €4.85 on different exchanges, against an official value of approximately €10.
They join a mixture of restrictions, suspensions and liquidations announced during 2026. The affected products include Wertgrund WohnSelect D, Fokus Wohnen Deutschland, Habona’s local-supply fund, KanAm’s Leading Cities Invest and UBS (D) Euroinvest Immobilien. Investmentcheck counts nine funds subject to one or more such measures this year.
Investors withdrew a net €5.9bn from open-ended property funds in 2024 and €7.6bn in 2025, according to the Bundesbank. Morningstar recorded another €3.7bn between January and July this year, taking the total to €17.2bn before the latest closures and restrictions.
Since 2013, most investors have been required to hold their units for at least 24 months and give twelve months’ notice before redemption. The rules were intended to prevent the sudden runs that destabilised the sector after the financial crisis. They turned an immediate run into a visible queue, giving managers time to raise cash, but did not remove the mismatch between redeemable units and buildings that can take months to sell.
DWS has now demonstrated the limitation. Reaching the end of the notice period no longer ensures repayment. An investor can wait twelve months, receive 10% and then face another notice period for the remainder.
Returns provide little reason to remain patient. Scope calculated that open-ended property funds lost an average of 1.2% in 2025 and expects another decline of between 0.5% and 1.5% this year. Government bonds, deposits and savings accounts once again offer positive returns without requiring investors to wait for a building to be sold.
DWS has already used much of its available room. Grundbesitz europa, whose assets have fallen from approximately €10bn five years ago to just over €4bn, had short-term borrowing equal to 8.7% of the fund, close to the statutory ceiling of 10%. Its overall leverage of 29.4% was just below the 30% limit. Liquidity stood at 5.8% at the end of August, barely above the statutory minimum of 5%, before two sales reportedly lifted it to 7.9%.
Other managers face the same calculation. Union Investment sold 28 properties worth around €3bn from its three commercial funds during 2025 and 2026, raising their liquidity ratios to between 13% and 21%. DWS says substantial portions of its portfolios are also in sales processes.
The redemption queue becomes a sales pipeline
The funds are consequently becoming some of the property market’s most dependable sellers. Suspended funds can wait, but not indefinitely. If the Swiss Life fund cannot reopen, it may sell properties at up to 10% below their appraised market values after twelve months and up to 20% below after 24 months. If it remains unable to resume redemptions after 36 months, liquidation becomes compulsory.
That timetable may prevent an immediate fire sale, but the need to sell remains. Liquidating funds will add supply for years, while those remaining open must raise cash before further redemption notices mature.
The pressure also exposes the gap between the stable valuations supporting official fund prices and the prices obtainable when properties or units must actually be sold. According to Investmentcheck, the appraised values of the Swiss Life fund’s properties rose during 2021/22 and again during 2022/23, a financial year spanning the interest-rate reversal. Across the four years to June 2025, the net change remained slightly positive. The fund now concedes that further sales are possible only with substantial price reductions.
Exchange discounts have appeared among larger funds too. Grundbesitz Global has traded approximately 46% below its redemption price. Even UniImmo: Europa, one of Union Investment’s flagships, recently traded at around €36 against an official redemption price of approximately €46. Persistent discounts of this scale indicate that buyers do not accept official fund values as readily realisable.
An academic study presented around Expo Real illustrates how quickly reassurance can become obsolete. Steffen Sebastian, Ulrich Nack and Torben Reinhold divided each fund’s reported liquidity by its previous annual outflows to estimate how long the cash might last if withdrawals continued at the same rate. The Swiss Life fund had 7.3 years, the second-highest result. It suspended redemptions roughly a fortnight later. Grundbesitz europa scored 0.4 years.
The authors warned that their calculation was not a prediction of closure. It used dated annual reports, assumed constant outflows and treated reported liquidity as available. Subsequent events demonstrate the limitations: a liquidity ratio is a photograph, while redemption notices, operating requirements and attempted sales continue outside the frame.
The consequences extend beyond investors waiting for their money. Every disposal creates transaction evidence that valuers, lenders and owners of comparable assets must consider. Fund sales can therefore transmit redemption pressure into institutional portfolios, financing covenants and refinancing negotiations. For buyers with capital, the pipeline may produce opportunities. For existing owners, it may establish prices they had hoped the market would avoid.
A separate challenge may arrive from Luxembourg. The European Court of Justice is considering how the risk of open-ended property funds should be calculated under the EU’s PRIIPs rules. If it follows an earlier judgment from Nuremberg-Fürth, providers may have to place the products in risk class 6 of 7 or overhaul the methodology used to determine their classifications. The fund association BVI does not expect a decision before early 2027.
The largest managers insist they can cope. Commerz Real says hausInvest has €1.4bn of liquidity for announced redemptions, although it expects withdrawals to remain high. Union Investment argues that the commercial property correction is largely complete, while DWS expects prices to reach their floor this year.
The test will not be what the funds say about the end of the correction, but what they must sell and at what price. Germany’s post-crisis rules have slowed the withdrawal run and given managers more time to respond. They have not guaranteed investors their money when the twelve-month wait ends.
Whether the largest funds can work through the queue without further gates, substantial write-downs or distressed disposals will determine whether this remains a liquidity crisis among individual products or becomes a repricing of the wider market.